Originally posted 2014-08-04 23:08:47.
Eight major areas of contradiction between the Qur’an and Hadith literature
Below I have only given the headings of these topics and the list of narrations from Hadiths that contradict the verses of the Qur’an.
Punishment for adultery:
Al-Bukhari: 8.816; 3.885
Al-Qur’an: 24:2; 24:5-9
Extremely adverse comments supposedly made by the Prophet against women:
Al-Bukhari: 1.301; 7.30; 1.490;
Muslim 1032, 1034;
Abu Da’ud 703
Al-Qur’an 2.223; 4.19; 16.97; 33.35; 48:5-6
To approach women during their menses, for sexual purposes:
Al-Bukhari: 1.298; 1.299
Al-Qur’an: 2.222
Aspects of character ascribed to the Prophet:
Al-Bukhari: 7.590; 7:252/253/254; 9.130
The circumstances under which and when the parts of Qur’an were supposedly to have been revealed:
Al-Bukhari: 6.209; 6.203
Al-Qur’an: 11:114; 11:5
Celestial Science:
Al-Bukhari: 4.421
Al-Qur’an: 36:38
The companions of the Prophet:
Al-Bukhari: 5.546
Al-Qur’an: 48:29; 8:63
Can anyone intercede on our behalf:
Al-Bukhari: 8.567 & 571; 1.98; 1.331; 5.224; 6.242
Muslim 389, 747, 2071, 2516
Al-Qur’an: 39.44; 2.254/255; 25.30; 2.48 &123; 6.51/70/94; 9.114; 7.188; 7.53; 21.100; 30.13; 34.23; 11.46; 46.9; 36.23; 40:18; 43.86; 74.48; 111.1/3; 35.14; 10.3; 19.87; 20.109; 21.28